Scott Tuppen's Client Unanimously Acquitted on All Counts

In: News Published: Thursday 19 November 2026

Share

Scott represented a defendant charged with grievous bodily harm and perverting the course of justice at the Crown Court at Swansea. 

There was no dispute that the defendant had committed an assault and had caused serious bodily harm, namely broken the complainant's jaw in two places. However, the defendant maintained he acted in self-defence. The police seized a CCTV clip of the assault on the day but didn't obtain the full footage. The defence argued that this footage would have shown the complainant behaving aggressively towards the defendant for approximately 2 hours prior to the assault. The defence maintained that this was relevant contextual evidence that the jury had been deprived of but called on several witnesses to establish what had taken place immediately prior to the assault.

The defendant was also charged with perverting the course of justice based on a supposed phone call that he was said to have made to the public house where the altercation took place. The prosecution alleged that he had sought to persuade the landlord of the public house to delete the CCTV. The defendant maintained he had contacted the pub after being made aware that the short video clip of him punching the complainant was circulating (‘gone viral’) and he wanted the CCTV of the whole incident as he was being unfairly characterised as an unprovoked aggressor. The landlord, giving evidence, accepted that the remaining footage had been deleted, and the Detective Sergeant overseeing the case accepted that officers had not secured the CCTV despite attending the public house on the day of the incident.

The jury acquitted Scott’s client on both counts.

The case is another example of where a defendant’s liberty has been placed at risk because all relevant evidence was not secured in time. It highlights the importance of identifying potentially relevant video evidence at the outset of an investigation and securing that evidence before it is overwritten or automatically deleted. This case, and others like it, suggest that the law should be changed to (1) require data controllers retain data for a longer period of time than currently required; and (2) the Magistrates Court Act 1980 should be amended to provide a time limit for prosecuting indictable offences which is in line with the requirements to retain data.
Scott was instructed by Davies & Davies Solicitors.